The Farmer’s Dog Food

TL;DR

The Farmer’s Dog is a fresh-cooked, delivered dog food subscription that’s pre-portioned based on your dog’s calories — not scoops — so weight change usually means you need a calorie-plan adjustment. It’s a strong fit if you want fresh food convenience and you can handle freezer/fridge logistics, a slow transition, and a higher monthly cost (especially for big or highly active dogs). Before you commit, confirm your plan is labeled “complete and balanced” for your dog’s life stage, and loop in your vet if your dog has pancreatitis history, fat intolerance, or recurring GI upset.

What The Farmer’s Dog Actually Is

The Farmer’s Dog is a direct-to-consumer fresh dog food subscription. Instead of shelf-stable kibble or canned food, you get gently cooked meals shipped to your door, typically arriving frozen. The idea is simple: the food looks and handles more like perishable human food, and you feed it according to a calorie plan that’s customized to your dog’s profile (size, age, activity, body condition goals, etc.).

From a “what category is this?” standpoint, The Farmer’s Dog sits in the fresh subscription space alongside other delivered fresh brands. The day-to-day experience is different from kibble: you’ll be storing multiple packs in your freezer, moving portions to the refrigerator to thaw, and serving meals on a schedule. That convenience is real (no measuring cups, fewer “how much do I feed?” guesses), but it comes with a routine you have to maintain.

Nutritionally, the big checkpoint for any fresh (or home-style) dog food is whether it’s formulated to be complete and balanced for the right life stage. In the U.S., “complete and balanced” claims are typically tied to AAFCO nutrient profiles (or feeding trials). AAFCO’s nutrient profiles are commonly used as a benchmark for whether a diet is likely to meet a dog’s minimum nutrient needs when fed as the primary diet. In plain English: “fresh” doesn’t automatically mean “nutritionally complete,” and the label statement matters.

Another practical reality: because The Farmer’s Dog is calorie-portioned, weight loss or weight gain is often a math problem, not a “my dog needs a different texture” problem. If your dog is dropping weight, acting hungry, or getting soft stools, you’ll usually do better by adjusting the calorie plan (with the company’s support and your vet’s input when needed) rather than adding random toppers that can throw off nutrient balance.

Finally, food safety is part of the deal. The FDA’s pet food resources are a helpful baseline for owners on how pet food is regulated, how to check for recalls, and where to report problems. Fresh foods require careful storage and handling — especially in homes with kids, seniors, or immunocompromised family members. You can review the FDA’s guidance at FDA pet food information.

Who The Farmer’s Dog Fits Best

The Farmer’s Dog tends to fit best for owners who:

• Want a fresh-food format (and are comfortable with thawing/serving routines) rather than a bag-and-scoop approach.
• Like the idea of calorie-based portioning and are willing to monitor weight and body condition during the first few weeks.
• Have a picky eater or a dog that’s lost interest in kibble — fresh food can be more enticing for some dogs.
• Have the freezer space to store shipments and the fridge space to keep a couple of days thawed at a time.
• Want subscription convenience and don’t mind paying more for it — especially for small to medium dogs where monthly totals can feel more manageable than they do for giant breeds.

Aggregated buyer commentary from public reviews: Owners who like fresh subscriptions commonly highlight improved enthusiasm at mealtime (“my dog finally eats”), the convenience of pre-portioned packs, and how predictable the routine becomes once you get the thawing schedule down. Positive owner feedback also often mentions visible, trackable outcomes they care about — like steadier stools, fewer skipped meals, or better weight control — though these experiences vary by dog and by how carefully the transition is handled.

If your main goal is weight management, it can help to think like a vet team would: track body weight weekly for the first month and use body condition score as a reality check. If something looks “off,” adjust calories rather than improvising with extra treats or heavy toppers. Many veterinarians also use frameworks like the WSAVA Global Nutrition Guidelines to evaluate pet food companies (things like who formulates the diets, quality control, and how questions are answered).

Who Should Skip The Farmer’s Dog

The Farmer’s Dog is not the best fit for every household or every dog. We’d think twice (or talk with your vet first) if any of these apply:

• You’re on a tight monthly budget, especially with a large or highly active dog. Fresh subscriptions can become dramatically more expensive as calorie needs rise.
• You don’t have reliable freezer space or you dislike handling perishable foods (thawing, cleaning, tracking “use by” windows).
• Your dog has a history of pancreatitis, hyperlipidemia, or fat intolerance. Some dogs do poorly on higher-fat diets, and “fresh” diets can vary in fat levels by recipe. This is a vet-conversation category.
• Your dog is extremely GI-sensitive and tends to get diarrhea/vomiting with any change. You can still try fresh food, but you’ll need a slower transition and close monitoring.
• You’re feeding a puppy, a pregnant/nursing dog, or a medically complex senior and you haven’t confirmed life-stage appropriateness. For these dogs, the “complete and balanced for the right life stage” wording matters a lot.

Aggregated buyer commentary from public reviews: The most common “skip” themes owners mention with fresh subscriptions are sticker shock after the intro period, the hassle of freezer management, and dogs who get loose stools when owners transition too quickly. Some owners also report frustration when weight changes happen (up or down) and they realize they need to adjust calories rather than assuming the food itself is “too rich” or “not enough.”

Separately, if your dog has repeated vomiting, severe diarrhea, lethargy, or signs of abdominal pain during any diet switch, stop the change and call your vet. That’s not “normal adjustment,” and it’s not something to troubleshoot with guesswork.

UnKibble (Fresh Dry™ dog food)

Pricing and How to Buy

The Farmer’s Dog is sold primarily as a subscription, and the pricing tends to be driven by calories per day, not just your dog’s breed label. That matters because a lean, athletic dog can cost more to feed than a couch-potato dog at the same weight — fresh food pricing follows energy needs.

Here’s how we think about value with The Farmer’s Dog:

• What you’re paying for: fresh-cooked format, pre-portioned packs, delivery logistics, and a calorie plan tailored to your dog.
• What you’re not paying for: the cheapest cost-per-calorie. Kibble almost always wins on raw affordability, especially for large dogs.
• Where value feels best: small-to-medium dogs, owners who strongly prefer fresh food, and households that benefit from portioning simplicity (for example, multi-person homes where “someone fed her already” is a common problem).
• Where value can feel worst: big dogs, very active dogs, multi-dog households, and anyone who doesn’t have freezer capacity.

A practical way to avoid regret is to decide upfront whether you’ll feed The Farmer’s Dog as:

• A full diet (100%), where it needs to be complete and balanced for your dog’s life stage, or
• A partial diet/topper to stretch your budget.

If you go the topper route, keep in mind that once you start displacing a meaningful amount of a complete-and-balanced food, you can accidentally unbalance the overall diet. If you’re mixing foods long-term (especially for puppies), it’s worth asking your vet for guidance on how to keep the total diet nutritionally sound.

Common Mistakes When Trying The Farmer’s Dog

• Switching too fast. A rapid swap from kibble to fresh is one of the most common triggers for diarrhea or vomiting. A slower 7–10 day transition is a safer default for many dogs, and sensitive dogs may need longer.
• Using “volume” instead of calories. Fresh food can look like a smaller (or larger) portion than kibble, but what matters is the calorie total. If your dog is losing weight or still acting hungry, ask for a calorie adjustment rather than eyeballing bigger portions.
• Not confirming the life-stage statement. Before you treat any food as a primary diet, look for an AAFCO-style “complete and balanced” statement and make sure it matches your dog (adult maintenance vs growth/all life stages). AAFCO nutrient profiles are the common reference point for these claims.
• Changing treats and chews at the same time. If stools get soft, you won’t know whether it’s the new food or the new treats. Keep everything else stable for the first couple of weeks.
• Forgetting the cold-chain routine. Fresh subscriptions work best when you set a simple habit: move the next day’s portions into the fridge every night, thaw only in the refrigerator, and follow package guidance on how long thawed food can be stored.
• Overlooking fat sensitivity risk. If your dog has had pancreatitis or has known fat intolerance, don’t assume “fresh” equals “safe.” Ask your vet what fat targets are appropriate, and ask the company for typical nutrient ranges for the recipe you’re feeding.
• Not tracking weight early. We’d weigh weekly for the first month and take notes on stool quality and appetite. Early tweaks are easier than trying to correct a bigger weight swing later.

Aggregated buyer commentary from public reviews: Owners often describe two preventable issues: (1) GI upset after a fast transition, and (2) unexpected weight change when they assume the initial plan is “set it and forget it.” The owners who seem happiest with fresh subscriptions tend to treat the first 2–4 weeks as a test period — tracking weight and stools, then adjusting the plan instead of improvising with extra food add-ons.

FAQ

Is The Farmer’s Dog a complete and balanced dog food?

It depends on the specific recipe/plan and the life stage it’s intended for. Look for an AAFCO-style statement on the packaging or the company’s nutrition info that says the food is “complete and balanced” and specifies the life stage (adult maintenance, growth, or all life stages). AAFCO nutrient profiles are the common standard behind these statements (see AAFCO resources for background on how nutrient profiles are used).

How do I transition my dog from kibble to The Farmer’s Dog without diarrhea?

Most dogs do better with a gradual transition over about 7–10 days: start with a small amount mixed into the old food, then increase the fresh portion every couple of days. If stools loosen for more than a day or two, pause the increase (or step back) before moving forward again. Keep treats the same during the transition so you can clearly judge how your dog is handling the new food.

What should I do if my dog is losing (or gaining) weight on The Farmer’s Dog?

Don’t guess by adding extra toppers or cutting food randomly. Because the plan is calorie-based, the cleanest fix is usually a calorie adjustment — especially if weight is moving noticeably over 2–4 weeks. Track weekly weights and contact customer support to update the plan; if your dog has medical issues (thyroid disease, diabetes, GI disease, etc.), involve your vet.

Is The Farmer’s Dog safe for dogs with pancreatitis or high triglycerides?

This is a “talk to your vet first” situation. Dogs with pancreatitis history or hyperlipidemia often need a specific fat target, and different recipes can land differently for different dogs. If your vet approves a trial, monitor closely and stop the diet change and contact your vet promptly if you see vomiting, marked lethargy, or signs of abdominal pain.

How should I store and thaw The Farmer’s Dog meals?

Store shipped meals in the freezer, thaw portions in the refrigerator (not on the counter), and follow the package guidance for how long thawed food can stay refrigerated. Treat it like perishable human food: clean bowls and prep surfaces and wash hands after handling. For general safety and recall monitoring, the FDA pet food information page is a good resource.

Can I feed The Farmer’s Dog as a topper instead of a full diet?

Yes, many owners use fresh food as a partial meal/topper to reduce cost. The key is to avoid displacing so much of a complete-and-balanced diet that the overall day’s intake becomes unbalanced — this matters most for puppies and dogs with medical conditions. If you’re planning to feed a large percentage as fresh long-term, ask your vet what ratio makes sense for your dog.

How can I evaluate whether The Farmer’s Dog is a good-quality company?

Beyond “my dog likes it,” look for clear answers on who formulates the diets, what quality-control steps exist, and how the company handles nutrition questions. The WSAVA Global Nutrition Guidelines outline practical questions many vets use when evaluating pet food brands.

Bottom Line

The Farmer’s Dog is a legitimate option if you want fresh, pre-portioned meals delivered on a subscription and you’re ready for freezer/fridge handling, a slow transition, and ongoing calorie adjustments based on weight trends. It’s usually a better value for smaller dogs than for very large or high-calorie dogs, and it’s not a casual choice for dogs with pancreatitis history or fat sensitivity — those cases should start with your vet.

Methodology & disclosure: This brand guide synthesizes brand documentation, retailer/category research, and owner discussions. Brand claims are identified as company statements unless independently corroborated.

Affiliate disclosure: Some of the links in this article are affiliate links, meaning we earn a small commission if you make a purchase.