Petsafe vs Zippypaws for Crate Training

TL;DR

Crate training is often the most challenging phase of early dog ownership. Success depends heavily on the tools you use to keep your dog calm, occupied, and comfortable. PetSafe excels in providing durable, rubber-based toys and functional training gear that stands up to heavy chewers and determined puppies. ZippyPaws, on the other hand, focuses on mental enrichment and soft comfort, offering puzzle toys and slow feeders that turn a confined space into a rewarding environment. While PetSafe is generally the better choice for high-energy “destroyers” who need behavioral correction, ZippyPaws shines for anxious pets or those who need cognitive stimulation to settle down. Combining the durability of PetSafe for safety with the enrichment of ZippyPaws for mood is often the most effective strategy for long-term crate success.

Introduction: Why Your Brand Choice Matters for the Crate

When I first brought home my high-energy terrier, the crate wasn’t a “den”—it was a cage she desperately wanted to escape. I spent weeks testing different setups, and I quickly realized that the wrong toy or a flimsy bed can actually increase a dog’s anxiety rather than soothe it. The right tools make or break the crate experience because they define how your dog perceives that space. Is it a place where they get bored and frustrated, or is it a sanctuary where the best puzzles and softest mats live?

Choosing between PetSafe and ZippyPaws isn’t just about picking a brand; it’s about matching a philosophy to your dog’s specific personality. Some dogs need the rugged, utilitarian approach of PetSafe to stay safe and occupied. Others need the whimsical, brain-teasing designs of ZippyPaws to forget they are even in a crate. If you are looking for broader advice on setting the stage, our guide to pet gear and accessories breaks down the essentials for every budget.

In this guide, I’ll break down how these two giants compare in the specific context of crate training. We will look at durability, safety, and how real-world owners on Reddit have found these products to hold up under the pressure of sharp puppy teeth and separation anxiety.

The Core Philosophies: PetSafe vs ZippyPaws

PetSafe: Durability and Behavioral Correction

PetSafe has built its reputation on “tough.” Their products are often designed with behavioral science in mind, focusing on redirecting negative behaviors like destructive chewing or excessive barking. In the crate, PetSafe products act as a reliable anchor. Their Busy Buddy line, for example, is engineered from thick rubber that provides a satisfying chew while dispensing treats at a controlled rate. For a dog that might try to “eat” their way out of a crate, PetSafe offers the structural integrity you need for peace of mind while you’re out of the house. You can find similar heavy-duty recommendations in our review of best training aids for high energy dogs.

ZippyPaws: Mental Enrichment and Aesthetic Design

ZippyPaws takes a completely different approach. They prioritize “brain work” and comfort. Their famous “Burrow” toys—where a dog has to pull small squeaky items out of a larger plush base—are fantastic for keeping a dog’s mind busy in a small space. While PetSafe focuses on the physical act of chewing, ZippyPaws focuses on the cognitive act of problem-solving. Their aesthetic is also much softer and more “home-friendly,” which appeals to owners who want their dog’s gear to look as good as it performs. However, as we’ll discuss later, that softness comes with a trade-life for aggressive chewers.

PetSafe vs ZippyPaws Comparison Table

Individual Product Reviews

PetSafe Busy Buddy Barnacle

The Barnacle is a staple for anyone whose dog views a standard plush toy as a 30-second snack. It’s made of heavy-duty rubber and features “Treat Meter” prongs that you can trim to adjust how easily kibble or treats fall out. In my experience, this is the best toy for high-energy dogs who get “crate-frustrated.” It gives them a physical outlet for their energy that doesn’t involve chewing the crate bars. It’s much tougher than most standard rubber toys on the market.

The Good

• Extremely durable rubber that withstands aggressive chewers.
• Customizable treat flow keeps dogs engaged longer.
• Multi-textured surface helps with dental health during chewing.

The Bad

• The internal “Treat Meter” prongs can be very difficult to clean if you use peanut butter or wet food.
• It’s heavy—if your dog drops it on a plastic crate tray, it makes a loud bang that might startle anxious pets.

Our Take: Best for high-energy dogs who need a durable, long-lasting distraction. Skip if your dog is a timid chewer or if you hate cleaning small crevices.

ZippyPaws Burrow Log with Squirrels

This is the ultimate boredom buster for dogs that love to “hunt” or “dig” at their bedding. The toy consists of a plush “log” with three holes and three small squeaky squirrels. Your dog has to work to pull the squirrels out. It’s fantastic for crate training because it encourages focused, quiet play. I’ve found that even dogs who aren’t usually interested in plush toys get obsessed with the “extraction” process. It’s a great mental workout that tires them out for a nap.

The Good

• Highly engaging puzzle that provides significant mental stimulation.
• Replacement “miniz” (the small squeaky toys) are available if one gets lost or destroyed.
• Soft texture makes it a safe “snuggle” companion once the game is over.

The Bad

• Not for “rippers.” If your dog likes to de-stuff toys, the log will be in pieces in minutes.
• The squeakers are quite loud, which might be annoying if the crate is in your bedroom at night.

Our Take: Best for smart dogs who need mental puzzles to stay calm. Skip if your dog has a history of tearing open plush toys to find the stuffing.

ZippyPaws Happy Bowl Hamburger

Feeding meals inside the crate is the #1 way to build a positive association with the space. However, many dogs inhale their food in seconds, which doesn’t provide much “happy time.” The Happy Bowl Hamburger is a slow feeder that turns a 30-second meal into a 5-minute activity. The ridges and valleys of the “hamburger” design require the dog to use their tongue and nose to get the kibble out. It fits easily into most standard crates and is a lifesaver for dogs prone to bloat or digestive upset from eating too fast.

The Good

• Drastically slows down eating speed without frustrating the dog.
• Cute, vibrant design that makes mealtime feel like a game.
• Easy to clean in the dishwasher (top rack).

The Bad

• The plastic is lightweight. If your dog gets bored after finishing the food, they might start chewing on the bowl itself.
• No non-slip base, so it can clatter against the crate floor if your dog is an enthusiastic eater.

Our Take: Best for fast eaters who need to spend more time “loving” their crate during meals. Skip if your dog is an aggressive chewer of plastic.

PetSafe Easy Walk Harness

While not a crate toy, the Easy Walk is vital for the “crate-to-outside” transition. Many puppies are so excited to get out of the crate that they bolt or pull hard on the leash. This harness features a front-chest attachment that gently steers the dog to the side when they pull, redirecting their attention to you. I love that it doesn’t cross over the throat, so there’s no choking or gagging. It’s a tool that builds better manners immediately upon leaving the crate. For more on this brand, see our PetSafe vs ZeeDog for active dogs comparison.

The Good

• Effective “no-pull” design that works on most breeds.
• Easy to put on—no need to pull it over the dog’s head.
• Quick-snap buckles make it fast to gear up after crate time.

The Bad

• If fitted poorly, it can cause chafing behind the front legs.
• It is not a “safety harness” for the car; it is strictly for walking.

Our Take: Best for strong pullers who need better manners when leaving their crate. Skip if you have a dog with very sensitive skin or a deep chest that requires a custom fit.

Snuggle Puppy Calming Aid

Crate training a puppy often involves long nights of whining. The Snuggle Puppy is a “cuddle buddy” that features a “Real-feel” pulsing heartbeat and an optional heat pack. It mimics the sensation of sleeping with littermates. When I used this with a foster puppy, the crying stopped almost instantly. It’s a psychological tool as much as a physical one. It’s particularly effective for dogs with separation anxiety. For similar needs, check our guide on Kurgo vs PetSafe for anxious dogs.

The Good

• Reduces anxiety and crying significantly during the first few weeks of crate training.
• The heartbeat is surprisingly realistic and has a long battery life.
• Machine washable (after removing the heartbeat mechanism).

The Bad

• Expensive for a “plush” toy.
• A determined puppy can chew through the velcro to get to the plastic heart mechanism inside.

Our Take: Best for young puppies or anxious rescues adjusting to a new home. Skip if your dog is an aggressive “de-stuffer” of plushies.

Washable Pet Mat

Crate accidents are inevitable. Instead of bulky beds that are hard to clean, a high-quality washable mat is the practical choice. These mats often fit standard crate sizes perfectly and feature a removable cover. In my testing, these mats hold up to frequent cycles in the laundry without losing their softness. They provide just enough cushion to keep your dog off the plastic tray without being so plush that they encourage chewing or “nesting” behaviors that lead to destruction.

The Good

• Removable covers that handle mud, urine, and hair easily.
• Fits perfectly into standard crate dimensions.
• Low profile prevents puppies from getting “stuck” or tripping on deep padding.

The Bad

• Not very thick. If you have an older dog with joint issues, they may need more support.
• The “waterproof” liners can sometimes make a crinkly noise that bothers some dogs.

Our Take: Best for puppies in training or messy dogs who spend time outdoors. Skip if your dog has severe orthopedic needs.

What Real Users Are Saying (Reddit Insights)

General Sentiment

Across subreddits like r/puppy101 and r/dogs, the consensus is that a “hybrid” approach is best. Users generally trust PetSafe for the “serious” work of crate training—like keeping a dog busy for an hour—while ZippyPaws is praised for providing the “cute” and “mental” breaks that keep a dog happy. Owners often mention that the PetSafe Busy Buddy line is one of the few things they feel safe leaving in the crate unsupervised, whereas ZippyPaws is seen as an “active supervision” toy.

Top Complaints & Warnings

The community is vocal about specific durability issues. For ZippyPaws, the most common warning involves their leash pouches and small toys.

“The ZippyPaws leash pouch is super convenient, but the con is that if you have small treats, they can come out of the poop bag hole. I lost half a bag of training treats on a walk because of that design.” — r/puppy101

Another frequent complaint involves the “smell” of crate bedding. Dogs who spend time outdoors often develop a specific odor that lingers in the crate.

“My puppy has this weird salty smell that happens when she’s outside for a while. It’s super weird and smells like she’s been swimming in the ocean. Getting a bed with a truly washable cover is the only way to keep the crate from smelling like a wet pier.” — Reddit user feedback

Budget Tips & Value Picks

Reddit users often suggest that you don’t need the most expensive bed for a puppy. A simple, washable mat that fits the crate tray is often more durable and easier to manage than a $100 orthopedic bed that might get chewed up during a bout of separation anxiety. For those looking for value, the community highly recommends the ScratchMe Dog Training Pad as a durable alternative to traditional crate mats.

Product Head-to-Head for Crate Scenarios

Distraction: PetSafe Busy Buddy vs. ZippyPaws Burrow

If you have a bored puppy that is prone to barking, you need a distraction. The PetSafe Busy Buddy is built for the long haul. It requires the dog to physically gnaw on the rubber to release the food, which is a calming activity for most dogs. However, the ZippyPaws Burrow wins on engagement. Most dogs find the “searching” aspect of the Burrow log more mentally exhausting than just chewing.
Winner: PetSafe for durability; ZippyPaws for mental fatigue.

The Mess Factor: PetSafe Training Pads vs. Washable Mats

PetSafe offers high-quality disposable pads, but for crate training, many owners are moving toward washable mats. The Washable Pet Mat is more eco-friendly and, in the long run, cheaper. However, if your dog is a “scratcher” who likes to dig before they lie down, a disposable pad can be shredded in seconds. A heavy-duty washable mat with a durable cover is the superior choice for a crate environment. For more crate options, see our best training crates for puppies.

Other Notable Alternatives Worth Considering

• KONG Classic: The gold standard for crate training. Similar to PetSafe but with a slightly different shape that bounces unpredictably. Check Price
• ScratchMe Dog Training Pad: A rugged, thin mat that is perfect for dogs who like to scratch their bedding. It’s affordable and stands up to puppy teeth. Check Price
• Earth Rated Poop Bags & Dispenser: While not for inside the crate, these are essential for the post-crate bathroom run. The dispenser is much sturdier than generic versions. Check Price

Best Crate Gear by Segment

Best for ‘The Destroyer’ (Heavy Chewers)

If your dog turns every toy into confetti, stick with the PetSafe Busy Buddy Barnacle. The rubber is dense enough to survive aggressive jaw pressure, and the lack of fabric means there is nothing to rip or swallow. Check its detailed review here.

Best for ‘The Worrier’ (Anxious Puppies)

For the dog that shakes or whines the moment the crate door closes, the Snuggle Puppy Calming Aid is a must-have. It provides a biological comfort that hard rubber toys simply cannot match. You can read more about how it works above.

Frequently Asked Questions

Conclusion: Building a Hybrid Crate Kit

Successful crate training doesn’t require choosing just one brand. In fact, in 2026, the best setups almost always use a combination of PetSafe’s rugged durability and ZippyPaws’ mental enrichment. Start with a foundation of safety—a PetSafe Busy Buddy for unsupervised chewing and a PetSafe Easy Walk Harness for better manners on the way to the yard. Then, layer in the fun with a ZippyPaws Burrow for brain work and a Happy Bowl to make mealtime last longer.

Remember that every dog is an individual. What works for a calm Senior dog won’t work for a teething Belgian Malinois. Be honest about your dog’s chewing habits and anxiety levels before choosing. If you’re still exploring, browse our other dog products to find the perfect fit for your home. With the right tools and a little patience, the crate will eventually become your dog’s favorite place to be.

Some links below are affiliate links, meaning we earn a small commission if you make a purchase.

Affiliate disclosure: Some of the links in this article are affiliate links, meaning we earn a small commission if you make a purchase.